ALAPAAfro-Latino Association for Policy & Advocacy
StoriesPolicy

Invisible Behind Bars: How Anti-Blackness Shapes U.S. Immigration Detention and Erases Black Migrants from the Data

ICE tracks nationality, not race, so Black migrants, especially Afro-Latinos, vanish from the official count. Even the undercounted numbers show harsher bonds, more abuse complaints and six times the rate of solitary confinement.

Graphic reading “Uncounted. Unprotected.” beside a bar comparing Black migrants’ 4% share of ICE detainees with their 24% share of people held in solitary confinement

When public debates turn to United States immigration enforcement, the conversation almost always centers on the southern border through a monolithic lens. Yet inside the sprawling network of federal detention centers, private prisons, and county jails overseen by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), a distinct and severe crisis plays out along racial lines.

For Black migrants—whether they are Afro-Latinos from Cuba, the Dominican Republic, Colombia, and Honduras, or immigrants from Haiti, Jamaica, Nigeria, and Cameroon—the U.S. immigration system does not operate in a vacuum. Instead, it merges punitive border policies with the deeply entrenched anti-Blackness of the domestic criminal legal system.

Even more alarming, the true scale of how many Black people are locked inside immigration detention remains largely obscured. Because federal agencies fail to properly track race and ethnicity, thousands of Black detainees—especially Afro-Latinos—are systematically undercounted, rendering their disproportionate suffering invisible in official government records.

The Data Blind Spot: Why the Real Numbers Are Higher Than Reported

If you look for an official federal headcount of how many Black people are currently held in ICE custody, you will not find one. Unlike local police departments, state prisons, or the U.S. Census, the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and ICE do not systematically collect or publicly release racial demographic data on the people they detain.

As investigations by the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ) and data analyses from Syracuse University’s Transactional Records Access Clearinghouse (TRAC) have documented, ICE tracks country of citizenship rather than race. Consequently, civil rights researchers and journalists are forced to rely on an imperfect workaround: using nationality as a proxy for race by counting individuals from predominantly Black nations in Africa and the Caribbean.

This statistical loophole creates a massive undercount for two critical reasons:

  1. The Erasure of Afro-Latinos: When an Afro-Cuban, Afro-Colombian, Garifuna, or Black Dominican migrant is detained by ICE, federal databases record only their Latin American nationality. In government spreadsheets and public policy analyses, their Blackness is completely erased. Because Latin America is home to over 130 million people of African descent—and Black Latinos frequently face heightened policing and targeted displacement in their home countries—counting only African and Caribbean nations leaves out a substantial portion of the Black detained population.
  2. Multi-Racial and Diaspora Blind Spots: Migrants of African descent arriving from European nations, South America, or diverse Caribbean territories like Belize and Trinidad and Tobago are similarly misclassified or omitted from nationality-based proxy counts.

As a result, when researchers and reporters cite that Black migrants make up roughly 4% to 6% of the official ICE detention population, those figures represent an absolute floor, not a ceiling. The true number of Black people behind detention bars is significantly higher.

Disproportionate Targeting: From Street Policing to Deportation

Even with conservative proxy estimates that undercount Afro-Latinos, the available data exposes glaring racial disparities at every stage of the enforcement pipeline.

  • The Policing-to-Deportation Pipeline: Black immigrants are disproportionately swept into ICE custody through domestic racial profiling. According to research by the Black Alliance for Just Immigration (BAJI) and NYU School of Law, as highlighted in reporting by Capital B News, while Black people make up roughly 5.4% of the undocumented population in the U.S., they account for 20.3% of all immigrants facing deportation on criminal grounds before the Executive Office for Immigration Review. Furthermore, BAJI’s data reveals that 76% of deported Black immigrants had prior contact with the police or the criminal legal system—a direct consequence of over-policing in Black and Brown neighborhoods. Once convicted of an offense, Black immigrants face a 76% chance of deportation—and 83% for Caribbean immigrants—compared to 45% for the overall immigrant population.
  • Higher Bonds and Longer Stays: Once detained, Black migrants face steeper financial barriers to freedom. According to bond data analyzed by the legal nonprofit RAICES, the average immigration bond set for Haitian migrants is $16,700—roughly 54% higher than the average bond required for other immigrant groups. Unable to pay inflated bonds, Black detainees languish in custody for months or even years longer than non-Black detainees.
  • Asylum Denials: At the border and in immigration courts, Black asylum seekers encounter systemic skepticism. According to a submission to the United Nations by Human Rights First, Sub-Saharan African asylum seekers face negative credibility findings at rates 37% higher than average, while Haitian asylum seekers experienced an 82% denial rate over a two-decade span.

Extreme Abuse and Isolation Inside Detention Walls

Inside detention facilities—many of which are operated by for-profit prison corporations in the American South—anti-Black bias translates directly into physical violence, medical neglect, and psychological torture.

A joint investigation by Freedom for Immigrants, BAJI, the UndocuBlack Network, and the Black LGBTQIA+ Migrant Project—reported by the Los Angeles Times—analyzed nearly 17,000 calls made between 2016 and 2021 to the National Immigration Detention Hotline. Their findings uncovered staggering disparities:

  • Disproportionate Abuse: According to the Los Angeles Times summary of the report, although people from predominantly Black countries accounted for just 6% of the tracked ICE detainee population, they filed 28% of all abuse-related complaints.
  • Severe, Life-Threatening Cases: According to the American Immigration Council, 53% of the most severe, high-intensity human rights cases requiring urgent intervention involved Black migrants.
  • Solitary Confinement as Punishment: A landmark study by University of California researchers, published in partnership with the International Consortium of Investigative Journalists (ICIJ) and cited by the ACLU of Maryland, found that ICE placed detained immigrants from majority-Black African and Caribbean countries in solitary confinement at six times the rate of the general detained population. Accounting for just 4% of tracked detainees during the study window, Black migrants made up 24% of everyone locked in solitary isolation.
  • Compounded Vulnerability: According to Freedom for Immigrants, in detention facilities across Alabama, Georgia, and Louisiana, Black detainees are nearly twice as likely to experience abuse compared to non-Black peers, while Black non-binary and LGBTQ+ migrants face 3.5 times the risk of abuse while in custody.

For Afro-Latino detainees, this violence often carries an added layer of isolation. Placed in housing units segregated by language or nationality, Afro-Latinos frequently report facing anti-Black discrimination from guards and fellow detainees alike, while simultaneously being denied culturally competent translation services or advocacy networks that recognize their dual identity.

The Policy Mandate: Counting Everyone to Protect Everyone

The erasure of Blackness within ICE’s data systems is not merely a clerical oversight; it is a policy failure that shields systemic human rights abuses from federal accountability. When agencies refuse to record race alongside ethnicity and nationality, lawmakers cannot accurately measure racial disparities, civil rights attorneys struggle to prove patterns of discriminatory enforcement, and Afro-Latino migrants remain caught in a statistical blind spot.

According to policy blueprints issued by the American Immigration Council, BAJI, and Freedom for Immigrants, meaningful reform requires several immediate policy shifts:

  • Mandatory Racial and Ethnic Disaggregation: Congress and the Department of Homeland Security must mandate the collection and public reporting of self-identified race and ethnicity data across all ICE arrests, detention facilities, bond hearings, and deportation proceedings—explicitly allowing migrants to identify as both Black and Hispanic/Latino.
  • Ending Local Police Collaborations: Repealing programs like 287(g) that deputize local police to act as immigration agents, thereby severing the pipeline that turns racially profiled traffic stops in Black and Afro-Latino neighborhoods into deportation orders.
  • Oversight and Abolition of For-Profit Detention: Establishing independent civil rights oversight with subpoena power over detention conditions while phasing out mandatory detention and private prison contracts that profit from the prolonged incarceration of Black migrants.

Until federal policy recognizes that Black immigrants come from across the entire globe—including the Spanish-speaking Americas—thousands of Black lives will remain uncounted, unprotected, and locked away behind detention walls.


Dr. Richard Nuñez-Lawrence is the founding Executive Director of the Afro-Latino Association for Policy and Advocacy (ALAPA).

ALAPA, the Afro-Latino Association for Policy & Advocacy, is a New York nonprofit for Afro-Latinos across the Americas and the Caribbean.