ALAPAAfro-Latino Association for Policy & Advocacy
StoriesPolicy

Broken Windows Rebranded: What the Data Reveals About Over-Policing in New York City’s Black and Latino Neighborhoods Today

Low-level enforcement is surging again in New York City. Black and Latino residents are half the population but received 81.8% of criminal summonses, and police data still can’t show how Afro-Latinos are affected.

Graphic reading “Broken windows, rebranded.” beside bars comparing Black and Latino New Yorkers’ 50.4% share of the city’s population with their 81.8% share of NYPD criminal summonses

When Mayor Zohran Mamdani took office in January 2026 after campaigning on a public-health vision of safety that rejected punitive “quality-of-life” policing, civil rights advocates expected a decisive break from New York City’s past. Yet less than a year into the administration, public defenders, court monitors, and data researchers are sounding an alarm: low-level enforcement in Black and Latino neighborhoods is surging once again.

For Afro-Latino New Yorkers—who navigate the intersection of anti-Black racial profiling and anti-Latino bias—this resurgence feels painfully familiar. Examining newly released 2025 and 2026 enforcement data alongside the legacy of Rudy Giuliani’s 1990s “Broken Windows” regime reveals whether claims of modern over-policing hold up under statistical scrutiny, how municipal databases erase Afro-Latino identity, and what proven strategies can keep New York safe without criminalizing communities of color.

Then vs. Now: Comparing Giuliani’s “Broken Windows” to 2026 Enforcement

Under Mayor Rudy Giuliani and Police Commissioner William Bratton in the 1990s, the NYPD institutionalized “Broken Windows” policing—a strategy predicated on the theory that aggressively arresting and ticketing people for minor infractions like turnstile jumping, loitering, public drinking, and marijuana possession would deter violent felonies. As documented in criminological analyses published in the African Journal of Criminology and Justice Studies, the 1990s strategy produced massive racial disparities in misdemeanor arrests while failing to prove that low-level crackdowns caused the decade’s crime drop.

In 2026, total raw arrest numbers remain lower than their 1990s and early-2000s peaks, and NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch has framed modern Quality of Life divisions around addressing “daily nuisances” rather than using minor infractions as a pretext for felony prevention. However, the statistical data confirms that the claim of modern over-policing in Black and Latino neighborhoods is entirely valid:

  • A Five-Fold Surge in Criminal Summonses: According to the New York City Criminal Summons Dashboard launched in November 2026 by the Data Collaborative for Justice (DCJ), criminal summonses issued by the NYPD jumped nearly fivefold between 2021 and 2025. While Black residents make up 21.9% of New York City’s population and Hispanic or Latino residents account for 28.5%, Black New Yorkers received 47.5% of all criminal summonses and Hispanic New Yorkers received 34.3%—meaning Black and Latino residents absorbed 81.8% of low-level citations. Fewer than 10% of those summonses even resulted in a conviction.
  • 220,802 Low-Level Summonses in FY 2026: As reported by the New York Daily News and The Legal Aid Society, the Mayor’s Fiscal Year 2026 Management Report—covering the final six months of the Adams administration and the first six months of the Mamdani administration—showed the NYPD issued 220,802 low-level summonses, a 13% increase over the prior fiscal year.
  • Arraignment and Arrest Disparities: According to official city metrics published by EquityNYC, overall NYPD arrests rose for five consecutive years—jumping 99% between 2020 and 2025—with Black and Hispanic New Yorkers accounting for 83% of all arrests and 88% of youth in detention. Meanwhile, court-monitoring data compiled in August 2026 by Court Watch NYC and reported by the Queens Daily Eagle found that 57% of observed arraignments were misdemeanors and 93% targeted people of color.
  • The Return of Street and Vehicle Stops: EquityNYC data shows recorded Stop, Question, and Frisk encounters nearly tripled since 2021 to reach 26,631 in 2025, with Black New Yorkers stopped at nearly 14 times the rate of white New Yorkers. An August 2026 federal monitor report cited by the Legal Defense Fund (LDF) found that 91% of individuals stopped by NYPD specialized units were Black or Hispanic, with unconstitutional frisks and searches routinely rubber-stamped in internal audits. Simultaneously, an analysis by the Community Service Society of New York (CSSNY) found that NYPD vehicle searches surged 83% in 2024 to 28,416 searches, with over 84% targeting Black or Latino drivers.

Over-Surveillance and the Afro-Latino Blind Spot in Justice Data

For Afro-Latino residents in neighborhoods like East Harlem, Mott Haven, Bushwick, and Crown Heights, aggressive quality-of-life enforcement compounds a unique structural vulnerability. On the street, officers profile Afro-Latinos through anti-Black racial heuristics—subjecting them to heightened stop rates, vehicle searches, and inclusion in the NYPD’s controversial Criminal Group Database, where an audit reported by Word In Black and the New York Civil Liberties Union (NYCLU) confirmed that 99% of listed individuals are Black or Latino. Once inside precinct houses and arraignment courtrooms, Afro-Latinos also face anti-Latino linguistic barriers, xenophobic assumptions regarding immigration status, and elevated bail demands.

Yet municipal justice systems fail to track Afro-Latino identity accurately:

  • Siloed Police and Court Categories: In NYPD Crime and Enforcement Activity Reports, individuals are classified into mutually exclusive categories such as “Black” or “Hispanic,” rather than capturing dual racial and ethnic identity. When an Afro-Dominican, Afro-Puerto Rican, or Garifuna New Yorker is arrested or issued a summons, they are recorded strictly as “Hispanic” or strictly as “Black,” obscuring how dark-skinned Latinos experience disproportionate stops, uses of force, and pretrial detention.
  • Distorted Bail and Sentencing Audits: Without disaggregated data linking race, skin tone/phenotype, and Hispanic ethnicity across NYPD arrest records, District Attorney charging decisions, and Office of Court Administration (OCA) bail determinations, policymakers cannot measure how intra-Latino colorism drives harsher outcomes in criminal court.

Keeping Crime Low Without Over-Policing: An Evidence-Based Blueprint

Reducing over-policing does not mean ignoring public safety or neighborhood quality of life. Decades of empirical evidence—including a landmark investigation by the NYPD Office of the Inspector General cited by the NYCLU—demonstrate that steep drops in quality-of-life summonses do not cause increases in felony crime. To protect Black and Afro-Latino communities while driving down violence, city and state leaders can enact four targeted reforms:

  1. Shift Quality-of-Life Response to Civilian Agencies: As advocacy groups and public defenders highlighted by the New York Daily News have urged, Mayor Mamdani should fulfill his campaign pledge to pull armed police units out of non-violent quality-of-life enforcement—such as street vending, homelessness, mental health crises, and subway fare disputes—and transfer those budgets to civilian crisis-response teams, sanitation, and social services.
  2. Disband Unconstitutional Specialized Units and the Gang Database: Following the August 2026 federal monitor findings cited by the Legal Defense Fund, City Hall should dismantle Neighborhood Safety Teams and abolish the secretive Criminal Group Database, redirecting investigative resources toward solving serious violent crimes and illegal gun trafficking rather than dragnet surveillance of Black and Latino youth.
  3. Invest in Community Violence Intervention (CVI): Expand funding for credible-messenger programs, Crisis Management System (CMS) Cure Violence sites, summer youth employment, and neighborhood lighting/infrastructure upgrades—interventions proven to reduce shootings without generating tens of thousands of low-level criminal records.
  4. Mandate Afro-Latino Data Disaggregation Across the Justice System: The City Council and State Legislature should require the NYPD, Department of Correction, and state court systems to adopt multi-select race and ethnicity reporting (allowing individuals to be recorded as both Black and Hispanic/Latino) across all stops, summonses, arrests, bail determinations, and solitary confinement logs—bringing full transparency to how policing impacts Afro-Latino New Yorkers.

Dr. Richard Nuñez-Lawrence is the founding Executive Director of the Afro-Latino Association for Policy and Advocacy (ALAPA).

ALAPA, the Afro-Latino Association for Policy & Advocacy, is a New York nonprofit for Afro-Latinos across the Americas and the Caribbean.